The Best Part of the Video Store Was the Wall

You didn't pick a Friday night rental. The wall picked it for you, usually with a painted cover that promised far more than the movie delivered. It was perfect.

Hemant Naidu·
The Best Part of the Video Store Was the Wall

If you're old enough, you remember the horror section in October.

It was usually toward the back of the store, as if the staff didn't quite want it near the kids' shelf. Floor to ceiling, face-out, every box competing for your attention at once. A hand reaching up out of a grave. A skull with something crawling out of the eye socket. A woman screaming at something just out of frame. Tagline in a font that looked like it was dripping. You'd stand there with a friend for twenty minutes, picking boxes up, flipping them over to read the back, arguing.

Half the time the movie was nowhere near as good as the cover. The painted art showed a creature the film's budget could never have afforded. The tagline promised a level of terror the actual ninety minutes didn't get close to. You'd drop it in the return slot on Sunday a little betrayed, and then you'd be back the next Friday doing it all again.

We knew the cover was lying. We rented it anyway, because standing in front of the wall was half the night.


The wall was also the same for everyone. Every person who walked into that store saw the same covers in the same spots. The new releases got the eye-level shelf. The cult film the staff loved got a handwritten card taped underneath. The weird one with the incredible cover sat on the bottom shelf until somebody brave took it home. When you argued with your friend about what to rent, you were arguing about the same thing.

Streaming works the other way round. The rows are built for you. Netflix has written publicly about personalizing artwork, choosing which image to show each viewer for the same title based on what they've watched before. Two people looking at the same film on two different couches can see two different pictures. It's clever, and I can see why they do it. It also means the shared wall is gone. There's no common shelf to argue in front of, because nobody's looking at the same shelf.

There's no bottom shelf either, where an odd little film sat waiting for someone curious enough to crouch. The row decides what you see, and the row is always trying to guess right.

The wall never guessed. It just showed you everything and let you get it wrong.


Collectors never really gave up the wall, though. We moved it home.

Walk into most collectors' rooms and look at how the shelves are arranged. A lot of people keep their favourites face-out. Some rotate them with the seasons, horror at the front in October, the Christmas films pulled out in December. Framed one-sheets go up in hallways and home theaters. The steelbook that cost more than it should have gets its own spot at eye level, just like a new release used to.

The boutique labels figured this out too. A lot of today's best special editions come with newly commissioned artwork, sometimes on a reversible sleeve so you can choose between the original theatrical art and the new piece. Somebody at those labels clearly spent a lot of Friday nights in front of a video store wall.

Even the new video stores opening this year talk about it. Dylan and Keri Wise, who run Little Movie Store in South Philly, are building a rental shop around about 7,000 titles on the floor, and Dylan told PhillyVoice the goal is for the place to feel "comfortable and not overwhelming for somebody to walk into."


I still stream, and the recommendation rows have found me a few good films. But I miss the version of choosing a movie where everyone saw the same art, the covers were loud and sometimes lying, and wandering was the fun.

The wall is still there if you want it. It's on your own shelves, in the order you put things, under the covers you chose. Right now, with Christmas coming, it might be the holiday shelf, face-out, every box competing for your attention at once.

Pick the one with the best cover. Let it disappoint you a little. That was always part of the deal.


Arkiv is a platform for keeping your collection, physical and digital, in one place. There are some fun things to uncover as your collection grows. Build your wall on Arkiv.

0 Comments

Sign in to join the discussion.